Bayville, NY Listings Local Resources Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Schultzy's Restaurant $ 72 reviews Seafood, Desserts, Salad (516) 588-6240 265 Bayville AveBayville, NY 11709 Mill Creek Tavern $$ 327 reviews American, Wine Bars, Seafood (516) 628-2000 275 Bayville AveBayville, NY 11709 Wild Honey $$$ 268 reviews New American, Seafood (516) 922-4690 1 E Main StOyster Bay, NY 11771 The Clam Bar At Bridge Marine $ 51 reviews Seafood, American, Live/Raw Food (866) 628-8689 40 Ludlam AveBayville, NY 11709 Sandbar $$$ 290 reviews Bars, Seafood, American (631) 498-6188 55 Main StCold Spring Harbor, NY 11724 Hidden Harbor Restaurant and Bar $ 7 reviews Cocktail Bars, American, Desserts (516) 226-1448 341 Bayville AveBayville, NY 11709 Gioia $$$ 53 reviews Pasta Shops, Cocktail Bars, Italian (516) 922-1660 94 South StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Ocean $$$ 477 reviews Seafood, American, Cocktail Bars (516) 628-3330 333 Bayville AveBayville, NY 11709 2 Spring $$$ 320 reviews New American, Wine Bars, Seafood (516) 624-2411 2 Spring StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Coach Meeting House $$ 78 reviews New American (516) 588-9288 160 Mill River RdOyster Bay, NY 11771 Piccolo Cantina Bay $$ 53 reviews Italian, Mexican, Seafood (516) 802-3001 18 Bayville AveBayville, NY 11709 Buckram Stables Cafe $$ 116 reviews American, Burgers, Breakfast & Brunch (516) 671-3080 31 Forest AveLocust Valley, NY 11560 The Audrey $ 7 reviews Restaurants, Wine Bars, Cocktail Bars (631) 358-3522 30 Audrey AveOyster Bay, NY 11771 American House Salad $ 25 reviews Salad, Breakfast & Brunch, Wraps (516) 922-2532 103 Pine Hollow RdOyster Bay, NY 11771 Rustic Root $$ 836 reviews New American, Breakfast & Brunch, Cocktail Bars (516) 364-3782 7927 Jericho TpkeWoodbury, NY 11797 Four - Chef's Counter in Oyster Bay $ 24 reviews New American, Seafood (516) 624-6877 4 Spring StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Two25 $ 32 reviews Italian, Wine Bars, Pizza (516) 676-5377 225 Birch Hill RdLocust Valley, NY 11560 Harbor Mist $$$ 297 reviews Seafood, Italian, American (631) 659-3888 105 Harbor RdCold Spring Harbor, NY 11724 Beach Bird $ 29 reviews Cafes (516) 240-2404 19 E Main StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Stellina Ristorante $ 52 reviews Italian, Pizza (516) 757-4989 76 South StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Oak & Vine $$$ 40 reviews New American, Cocktail Bars, Breakfast & Brunch (516) 200-9520 75 Cedar Swamp RdGlen Cove, NY 11542 The Homestead $$ 106 reviews Bars, American, Buffets (516) 922-9293 107 South StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Cafe Al Dente $ 54 reviews Italian (516) 922-2999 62 South StOyster Bay, NY 11771 Piñons Pizza Company $$ 74 reviews Pizza, Bars, Italian (516) 801-3200 23 Birch Hill RdLocust Valley, NY 11560